This lesson has two badges to unlock! Scroll down to view
Nighttime with a new puppy is rough. The first few weeks of puppy parenthood turn us all into the walking dead.
(Sometimes you have a brief honeymoon period, where the pup sleeps all night, doesn’t make a peep. But soon, they stop sleeping through the night and start getting fussy)
The first few nights can be super labor intensive; there’s a 99% chance your puppy will need a bathroom trip in the middle of the night. Most puppies under the age of four months are physically incapable of going all night without a bathroom break.
And once he’s sleeping through the night, he’ll probably wake up in the morning much earlier than you want to. They do this until at least five months old, typically.
The first step to surviving nights: Acceptance
It’s going to suck. There’s no getting around it. The sooner you embrace this fact, the better off you’ll be.
The next step: Minimize the suck as much as possible
Set up the sleeping arrangements in a way that decreases the fear and loneliness the pup will feel, being in a strange new place, likely away from their family for the first time ever.
How? Have the pup sleep in their crate right next to you.
Good idea: put the crate next to your bed at night for the first 10-14 nights.
Better idea, assuming you want the pup to eventually sleep outside your bedroom at night: put the crate in its permanent bedtime position from night one: the living room, and you sleep on the couch next to him. This will avoid the otherwise inevitable problem of the puppy screaming his head off when you eventually switch him from your bedroom to the living room.
Go with the good idea or the better idea, doesn’t matter to me. Either way, you increase your odds of getting SOME sleep, since Sparky is less likely to cry all night if he’s not banished to the laundry room. And even better, avoiding the trauma of being forced to sleep separately from you for the first few nights may decrease the odds of him developing separation anxiety.
Guide to the first night:
- Remove the pup’s access to water two hours before bedtime.
- Immediately before bed, take him for a bathroom break. If he doesn’t go, expect to have to try again in like 20 minutes.
- Next, put him in his crate with a really good chew, like a bully stick, or a frozen Kong. Hopefully, he’ll chew himself to sleep.
- Then get into bed next to him. If he gets fussy, stick your fingers through the crate bars to reassure him.
What to do about whining:
If he went to the bathroom immediately before bed: you can wait out the whining for thirty minutes before you have to try another bathroom trip.
If he did NOT go to the bathroom immediately before bed: take him to the bathroom.
Also, if the pup has been asleep for a while and then suddenly wakes up and starts whining, that’s the cue for a bathroom trip.
Nighttime bathroom protocol
To prevent the puppy from getting in the habit of using “I have to pee” as an excuse to have fun adventures, nighttime bathroom trips should be really boring. If possible, carry the pup to the bathroom, so he doesn’t get the excitement of walking. When he goes, this is the one time I recommend NOT rewarding with a treat. After he goes, wait a couple minutes to see if he goes again. Then carry him back to the crate.
But assuming the puppy doesn’t need to go to the bathroom, and this is just the usual fussiness, what should you do? There are a couple different techniques:
Technique one – stick your fingers through the bars to reassure him of your presence, but otherwise, just ignore the whining, let him “cry it out.”
Technique two – coach your puppy through it. This is what I chose. I talked to my puppies a lot. River, especially, was quiet as long as I was talking, so I talked her to sleep, while occasionally dropping pieces of kibble into the crate to reward her for quiet.
Either technique will work in the end, but now, having raised puppies with both methods, I personally prefer technique two. It seems to achieve the goals of the pup sleeping through the night faster, and the puppy becoming confident on their own faster.
Pro tip:
It might help you out, mentally, to decide that for the first 45 minutes after you and puppy get into bed, YOU are not going to sleep right away. Use this as “me time” to watch TV, read a book, scroll through your phone, or write in your journal while the pup gets his fussiness out of his system and falls asleep.
FAQ
“I’ve had my puppy for [insert length of time here] and we STILL can’t get through a single night without whining” and/or,
“I used a different method to sleep-train my puppy and it hasn’t worked. What do I do?”
Start from the very beginning. Even if you’ve had your pup for a month. Tonight, you’re going to treat him like it’s his very first night and use the above instructions.
“My puppy was improperly introduced to the crate, and now he’s terrified of it. What do I do?”
If Sparky panics when crated, don’t try to crate him overnight. Instead, use an exercise pen. If you don’t have one and can’t get one, use a tether to keep him in one spot. It’s probably not a good idea to use a leash as a tether, in case the puppy chews through it. Use either a lightweight metal chain leash or a steel cable dog tie-out. I’ve seen tie-outs at the dollar store and, while I wouldn’t trust any kind of dollar store pet restraint outside the house, they’re good for restraining puppies next to the couch overnight.
What next? Beyond the first few nights
So you’ve been sleeping on the couch next to your pup for a week. How do you start sleeping in your own bed again? The next lesson will show you exactly how I accomplished that feat with Hazel and River.
Puppy slept through the night for the first time
Earn this badge the first time your puppy stays quiet in their bed all night.
1 Step
- After settling down and going to sleep at bedtime, the puppy stays asleep (or at least doesn’t cry), until morning.
Puppy slept through the night: Seven nights
The end of your sleep deprivation is in sight! (Each night doesn’t have to be consecutive. Missing a night sometimes is normal)
7 Steps
- Earn the first Slept Through the Night badge
- After settling down and going to sleep at bedtime, puppy stays asleep. Night 2.
- Puppy stays asleep til morning. Night 3.
- Puppy stays asleep til morning. Night 4.
- Puppy stays asleep til morning. Night 5.
- Puppy stays asleep til morning. Night 6.
- Puppy stays asleep til morning. Night 7.


