UPDATE: In addition to the information below, we now have a separate workshop replay that goes into much more detail and answers common questions about this process. Check it out: Help! I’m a Prisoner in My Own Home
“When should I start this training?“
That depends. If you adopt your puppy on Saturday, and you have to go back to work on Monday, then you should prioritize home alone training during the weekend. It’s tempting to spend every possible second of that weekend with your new bundle of joy, but doing this work will help ease the difficult transition to “real life.”
If you have more time before your puppy will have to be left home alone for real, you can take a more relaxed approach. Ideally, you’ll start the training at least two weeks before the pup will be left alone for real.
“I’m already back to work. My main concern is my puppy crying when I leave. Do I need to be worried, and what should I do?“
I highly recommend setting up a camera so you can see exactly what the puppy does while you’re gone. You can figure out the severity of their separation issues this way.
Does the puppy cry for 10-15 minutes and then settle down? Or are they quiet most of the time, only seeming to get bored once in a while and crying for a few minutes? Both of those are good. That’s well within the category of “normal puppy behavior they’ll probably outgrow.”
For this pup, I would just do some things to make the experience easier for them. Before you go to work, make sure their mental stimulation and exercise needs are met: do some form of active play, and then a training session. The specific training you do during that session doesn’t matter, the point is just to put their brains to work. Pick something from the Baby Obedience course and work on it for 5-10 minutes every morning.
Then when you go to work, put them in their pen or crate with their breakfast in safe food-dispensing toys. (Use the solid rubbery types, like Kongs, not the fancy hard plastic ones with moving parts).
Pro tip: to keep them occupied longer, freeze the Kong the night before. If Sparky eats dry food, put the dry food in the toy first and then seal the opening with wet food or peanut butter.
But if the puppy cries and seems agitated for the whole time you’re gone:
That indicates their separation issues are more severe. It could also just indicate that the pup needed more time to settle in before these long separations happened. They may be too young, too new, and too bewildered by their new home.
In either case -severe separation issues or not enough time to settle in- your pup would benefit from a more structured, systematic desensitization approach. This means doing some brainstorming and problem-solving to figure out how to avoid leaving the puppy alone for real (can you leave Sparky at Grandma’s house when you go to work?), and doing the plan in the previous lesson. Take it step by step from the very beginning, with short physical-but-not-visual separations, all the way to you leaving the house for longer and longer periods of time.
“My puppy whines both when I’m home and he can’t see me, and when I leave the house. For the desensitization process, I know I’m supposed to gradually increase the dosage of alone time. But I have to go to work every day. I can’t slowly build up to one hour alone, then two hours, and so on til eight hours. So is there a point to working on this systematic desensitization at all?”
The short answer is yes, especially if your pup is of the less-severe category explained above, where they cry for a little while after you leave and then settle down. We’ll call this the FOMO puppy, like we talked about in alone training part 1.
FOMO puppies are pretty good at distinguishing between times when you’re home but not with them, and when you’ve left the house for the day. When you’ve left for the day, they can settle down because they know nothing interesting is happening. Might as well take a nap.
But when they’re in their crate, and you’re in the next room? That can set them off because they’re upset at not being able to hang out with you and be involved in whatever you’re doing. So yes, there is still value to working on desensitization. It’ll help with the alone-but-separate times.
Got more questions? Bring ’em over to the forum!
