What to do when you see warning behavior

So when a dog is giving agonistic signals, asking to increase distance, what should you do?

Help them increase distance. Whether the dog is baring their teeth or snarling, or running away, or hiding behind a person, you should calmly, happily call the dogs away from each other and/or lead them away by taking their collar or leash.

If the question is “should I let the dogs work it out,” the answer is almost certainly no. Especially when you’re introducing dogs who will, ideally, live together. Getting into fights or having tense interactions does not result in working things out, it only serves to build more tension and animosity between dogs.

The more two dogs are able to “practice” conflict, the harder it’s going to be to turn that around, and the worse the odds are for them being able to live together safely and happily.

There ARE cases where you can let an older dog correct a puppy or adolescent who needs to learn to take no for an answer when they want to play and the older dog doesn’t. But that’s only if you know the adult dog well and you know that they’re very good with dogs, and they’re not going to overreact and cause an actual fight. The reality is that a lot of dogs are NOT good with dogs, and not good at de-escalating conflict appropriately.

So yeah, the answer is almost always going to be to help the dogs de-escalate the conflict yourself.

Dogs oftentimes will ASK people for help. Dogs have very much evolved with the propensity to seek human assistance for all manner of issues, canine conflict included. If one dog starts jumping on a person or making eye contact, or coming over to stand real close to you, it’s very likely that dog is asking for help creating distance.

When we get to the practical introduction advice section, there’s a lot there about ways to alleviate the intensity of the interaction, which can go a long way toward helping the dogs feel better.