What makes Reactive Dogs, Shelter Dogs, and other Special Case Dogs Different
Dogs with issues like reactivity or resource guarding, and those with traumatic or unknown pasts such as abuse cases, strays or longer-term shelter dogs, often require a slightly different approach to introductions in general. With the vlogs and progress reports we’ll be posting here of our own special case dogs, this course will talk specific tactics for special cases later. Until then, we can take the lessons we learn about how behavioural issues and difficult pasts affect sociability, and apply them when planning dog intros.
These dogs typically already have a very long reinforcement or punishment history with many of the stimuli involved in introductions. This history causes them to develop some fairly strong conditioned emotional responses.
These dogs often already have fear or anxiety responses to other dogs, or many of the tools we often use to facilitate introductions, such as leashes or fences.
Some of them are highly protective of resources, which could be anything from food and water, to handlers and certain spaces. They may already come pre-programmed with fear responses to stimuli unrelated to the introduction but which can often be found in environments in which introductions are usually conducted – like loud traffic noises, or children, or skateboards, or even surfaces such as grass and pavement.
Why the Traditional Meet and Greet Introduction Style Doesn’t Work for Special Case Dogs
Traditional meet and greet introductions are pretty rude and triggering by the standards of these special case dogs.
This is borne out of necessity in a shelter environment – in which most traditional meet and greets happen – and out of unawareness between dog owners on the street.
Typically these meetings involve one or more restrictive barriers like leashes or fences, which can trigger barrier frustration, or a fight response in fearful dogs. In many cases, these introductions are not conducted with proper leash handling technique, which only exacerbates the problem for already triggered dogs.
The process often involves bringing the dogs directly towards each other, face-on, which can be extremely confronting even for dogs with a positive social history with other dogs. For a dog with a history of traumatic or aggressive interactions with other dogs, this can be perceived as a direct threat.
They almost always involve both dogs being accompanied by a handler, who often carries reinforcements in the form of treats or toys, which can cause some special case dogs to aggressively resource guard the reinforcements, the handler, or both.
Special case dogs may have strongly negative conditioned emotional responses to common stimuli which are often features of the uncontrollable or unideal environment in which introductions take place, and this reactivity may not be known to handlers beforehand.
Shelter dogs involved in meet and greets are almost always already in a heightened state of arousal, with stress hormone levels flying through the roof.
Alternatives
Conducting introductions with special case dogs requires us to be extra creative, extra patient, extra precise, and extra agile in our training.
For barrier or leash reactive dogs, this may mean employing some extra safety measures in order to reduce our reliance on barriers and/or leashes, or remove them altogether. Other safety measures might include things like muzzles and booties.
Leashes and barriers may still be appropriate in the early stages of introductions between these dogs, as we employ some DS/CC protocols at a distance, and slowly make our way towards each other over a longer period of time than a traditional meet and greet introduction. Leash and barrier-reactive dogs are often not reactive when training is conducted at distances that keep them under their threshold. This is because most barrier and leash reactivity arises from either frustration at being restricted from something they want to get to, or fear that their trigger is too close and they’re restricted from fleeing. With triggers far enough in the distance, we can often eliminate this element whilst still being close enough to at least passively introduce the dogs.
For fearful dogs, barriers such as fences and large open spaces are often the key to the first steps of successful introductions. Without the restriction of the leash, fearful dogs are free to use the space as they choose, and interact at whatever level they’re comfortable with.
So, too, are large open spaces and barrier fences a crucial tool in introductions with dogs who may resource guard their handlers, as we can step back and let dogs safely introduce themselves without the added conflict of a handler present.
Choosing the correct environment for introductions can also be crucial for special case dogs. For those who are reactive to traffic noises, we might consider travelling outside the city to do our introductions. For those who are stranger-reactive, or child-reactive, for example, we might consider using a dog sports or dog breed clubhouse after hours, or renting a space if either of these are options.
What We Can Expect
It’s important to be realistic about our expectations with socialising special case dogs. In the majority of cases, these dogs have already had a very long history of negative experiences that we will have to contend with – and often the length of this history is untold.
In general, special case dogs can take weeks to months to conduct a successful introduction, rather than the hours or days for most other dogs. It will likely take tens of sessions that will need to be done consistently.
Progress will often not be smooth. Special case dogs may have a number of good sessions in a row that show promising progress, only to come back next time and seem like they’re right back at the beginning, for reasons we often can’t identify.
Sometimes our special case dogs will refuse a session altogether, or will let us know that they aren’t comfortable with the pace at which this is going. We need to be willing to respect that, and expect that we’re going to have just as many setbacks and stalemates as we have successes.
And sometimes still, even if we do everything in our power, our special case dogs will never be comfortable with either the particular playmate we’re trying to introduce them to, or any playmate at all.
