Toys can be great reinforcers. Toy-based games often make appropriate functional reinforcers, because they encompass a lot of common motivators behind dog behavior, like social interaction and predation. And of course, games are always a good way to build your bond.
But you may need to take some time to build value for toys; dogs don’t always care right away.
To build value, we’re going to work on setting off and channeling your dog’s instinct to chase and destroy.
How to pick your toy
Different dogs like different kinds of toys, so you’ll have to experiment to find the one your pup will go nuts for. If there’s already a type of toy that your dog is obsessed with, great! Use that. But if you haven’t found that toy yet, start with something that simulates prey as much as possible. So a large furry plush toy.
Do not use a rope toy as your first attempt. Rope toys are boring. Again, it needs to look and feel like a prey animal.
Helpful hint: a good place to get large furry plush toys for cheap is at a thrift shop. Go to the children’s toys section and grab a few teddy bears.
(Yes, some kid’s once beloved teddy bear is now going to be ripped apart by your dog. The circle of life)
If you find that your dog is not already excited about toys, I wouldn’t start with something like a frisbee. Later, when your dog does enjoy toy play and they get the idea, you can introduce a frisbee if you’re so inclined. But for now: soft, fluffy, and ideally, squeaky.
How to begin value-building
Different dogs also enjoy different play styles. So again, experiment and see what happens.
Start by incorporating the toy into social play. So you’re not doing a lot of throwing the toy and telling them to go fetch, you’re holding onto it. And in the beginning, don’t worry about whether the dog will fetch perfectly, or perform an immediate Drop It when asked. Trying to enforce any type of “rules” at this stage may extinguish the tiny ember of enthusiasm that we’re trying to stoke.
Just be goofy and see what will get Sparky’s attention. And do this when they’re not distracted by something else. The same way you would want to start in a low-distraction setting when training your dog a new behavior, start in a low distraction setting here.
Play hard to get – don’t shove the toy into Sparky’s mouth. Prey doesn’t exactly happily jump into a predator’s mouth.
Try making it mimic the movement of a prey animal. Drag it on the ground in jerky, erratic movements. Hide it behind things, tease them by saying “look what iiii have!” and run away when Sparky goes after it. When they catch it, play tug.
You could even get another person involved and the two of you could play tug or throw the toy back and forth, which will kick off FOMO for a lot of dogs and they’ll want to come over and see what you’re doing.
We highly recommend getting a flirt pole, which is basically a giant cat teaser toy. Used properly, these tend to capture the attention of dogs who don’t otherwise care about fetch or tug. Flirt poles do a great job of mimicking the movement of prey, so they really activate the dog’s predatory motor sequence. (Stand-alone lesson on flirt poles coming soon)
Toy play examples
If your dog is more food-motivated than toy-motivated
If your dog still doesn’t see much point in engaging with toys, you can try using treats to jumpstart things. Do whatever it takes to get the dog to pay even the slightest bit of attention to the toy. Do all those prey-simulation movements with it, drag it around or wave it near their face. As soon as Sparky engages at all, maybe just by sniffing it or looking towards it, mark and reward with a treat. If you do this consistently for a while, you may start to see some of the value of the treats transfer into the toy itself.
Using toys as reinforcement
Check out this clip from the Beyond Treats webinar series. (This course covers a lot of what was originally in Beyond Treats, but you can still watch the full series here)
Key takeaways from the video:
When you start using toys as reinforcers, start with super simple and easy criteria and bite-sized training sessions. Ask for a behavior the dog already knows well, like Sit or Hand Target. Because dogs who aren’t used tor working for toys may need some help understanding the concept of “doing what my human wants gets me what I want.”
If you’ve worked through this course and used the Premack Principle, your dog should grasp that concept pretty quickly. But of course, always start on the easiest level to set them up for success.
When introducing non-food reinforcers like toys, patterns help. Work in the low-distraction area you often use for training, so it’s easier to get them into a training “head space.” Go into your toy-reward training session immediately after a food-reward training session. That way, Sparky will already be in the pattern of “do a sit, or a hand touch, or a whatever,” get a reward.
That won’t work for all dogs; if your dog is the food-obsessed type, they may get frustrated when the treats suddenly stop but you still want them to work. Speaking of which:
If your dog has food-motivation issues at either end of the spectrum (from not food motivated at all, to TOO food-motivated), check out the mini course How to Get Your Dog to Work For Food.
Capturing can also be used to introduce toy rewards. Which is especially useful if your dog is so not-food-motivated that they don’t already have any highly-reinforced cues like sit or hand target. Capturing means waiting for the dog to do the thing unprompted, and then rewarding them for it. Notice Sparky sitting down? Nice! Break out the tug toy.
Toys can also be used in capturing-based attention games like the ones we talked about in lessons 1 and 5:
