A breakdown of the dance moves: what’s okay and what’s not

Dog Introductions Demystified Play A breakdown of the dance moves: what's okay and what's not

In this lesson, we’ll go over signs that play is going fine, signs that you need to watch closely, and signs that you need to intervene. In the next lesson, we’ll analyze some video of play behavior, so you can see all this in action.

When in doubt, do a consent test

No matter how much you learn, there will be times when you just don’t know if the dogs are playing well or having an actual argument, and there’s no shame in being unsure and saying “maybe it’s time for a break.”

Separate the dogs, give them a moment to chill, and then let the “victim” go. If the victim goes right back to playing, you’re good.

Good play that you don’t have to worry about involves:

  • An invitation, and a yes. One dog sends a “play?” signal, and the other dog responds with a “yes play!” signal.
  • Alternatively: an invitation, a no, and a RESPECTED no. If Sparky asks Fido to play but Fido doesn’t give a yes, and Sparky moves on.
  • Give and take. They’ll take turns being the “aggressor.” If Fido has Sparky pinned, Fido will choose to let Sparky up after a while. Or they take turns being chased. Except in cases of dogs who really really looove to be chased, in which case, it’s fine if the chasing only goes one way. As long as there are breaks and check-ins, as described in my next point.
  • Breaks and check-ins. They’ll stop every thirty seconds or so. The break may be long or it may last only a couple seconds before someone gives a play invitation again. The dogs will take also stop and check in with each other, which they seem to do when they’ve accidentally gone too hard.
  • They’ll de-escalate when things get intense. Ideally, there’s an ebb and flow in intensity levels, where they’re regulating themselves.

Behavior that isn’t necessarily bad, but that you should watch closely:

  • A sudden rise in pitch in a dog’s vocalizations. This could indicate things are becoming too intense and they’re having trouble de-escalating.
  • A change in one or both dogs’ overall body language. Going from loose, bouncy movements to tense and rigid movements, or one dog suddenly tucking tail and giving “I don’t like this anymore” vibes.
  • One dog trying to disengage or end the game. Reducing their participation.
  • Putting their paws on the other dog’s back. This can be okay in certain contexts where the dogs are familiar with each other, and even sometimes between stranger dogs, if they both have the right temperament. But a lot of dogs do not appreciate this at all, so it’s something you want to be cautious of, especially in a situation where unknown dogs are interacting, like in a dog park.
  • One of the dogs ACTUALLY slamming the other to the ground. If you watch healthy dog play, you’ll notice that most of the time, the dog that winds up being “pinned” is actually flopping on the ground themselves. It’s a voluntary action, not something that’s done to them. Don’t get me wrong: actual body slamming isn’t always a bad thing, as long as both dogs are continuing to happily engage. A consent test will tell you if both dogs are having fun.

When to intervene:

  • One dog initiates play without waiting for a yes.
  • They’re not taking breaks, or one dog tries to take a break but the other ignores it and plows ahead.
  • The intensity keeps escalating, with no ebb and flow.
  • Multiple dogs ganging up on one dog, like in a dog park scenario. It’s possible that the “chasee” is perfectly happy with this arrangement, but the risk for trouble is high, so it’s wise to call the chasers off anyway and see if the chasee reengages.
  • Biting with headshake. Most dogs don’t appreciate being shaken, and even if they’re cool with it, there’s potential for injury.