Personality types and how they affect intros

Dog Introductions Demystified All about Introductions Personality types and how they affect intros

Everyone knows their dog has a personality. If you ask any dog parent to describe their dog to you, they won’t just give you a list of physical characteristics, they’ll write a whole online dating profile complete with Myers-Briggs results. 

But for now, in the context of dog intros, you can think of your dog’s personality as being: 

  1. Dog Aggressive
  2. Dog Tolerant
  3. Dog Selective, or
  4. Dog Social

And the average ratio of dogs in each of these categories can be best illustrated via the below graph:

As a society, and as a result of pop culture and the commodification of dog ownership, we have a preconceived idea that dogs are sociable creatures who are happy and joyful, and enjoy the company of both people and other dogs. However, as you can see by this graph, that’s not the reality.

In reality, most dogs are either Dog Tolerant or Dog Selective. A small portion are Dog Aggressive, and another small portion are Dog Social. 

So, what do these categories actually mean?

Dog Aggressive

Dog Aggressive dogs are those who actively dislike the company of other dogs in general, period. It’s not context dependent; they don’t like company sometimes or even very rarely. They hate it all the time. And they don’t just dislike them, they dislike them so much that they will display aggressive behaviour towards all other dogs in order to get them the hell away. 

Aggressive behaviour doesn’t always mean that there’s a full-on dog fight. We’re not talking about Cujo, here. These aren’t psychopathic serial killers out for blood. Aggressive behaviour can include hard stares, stiff body, growling and snarling, bared teeth, raised hackles, front-on stance, lowered head and heightened tail, all the way up to an actual bite. 

These dogs do not want any dog friends. They don’t want any other dog in their space, ever, under any circumstances and they will make sure they let everyone know that. 

Dog Tolerant

By and large, these dogs don’t really like other dogs, but they don’t hate them either. They don’t want friends, but they’ll be polite to other dogs who are in their space, up to a certain point. 

This doesn’t mean that these dogs will never display aggressive behaviour towards other dogs – no one can ever say that about any dog. As a general statement, they’re not seeking out the company of other dogs and would be perfectly happy to be left alone, but they’re not straight up going to aggress to any dog who interacts with them on principle. 

If your dog can be around most other dogs in most circumstances without aggressing, but they’re also never really displaying affiliative behaviours that invite other dogs to come interact, then they probably fall into this category. 

Dog Selective

These guys have some friends, but they’re not party animals by any stretch. They’ve usually got a few close friends who they’re happy to see and who they’ll invite to interact, but beyond that they’re not really interested. 

The majority of dogs fall into this category. They can usually be found being described as the dogs who “take awhile to warm up/come out of their shell”, “can by shy at first”, or are “great with dogs! Except for big dogs/small dogs/fluffy dogs/intact dogs/male dogs/young dogs….” etc. 

When they’re not socialising with the friends they have picked, they can either be dog tolerant or dog aggressive towards everyone else. Most dogs who are labelled as Dog Aggressive, are actually Dog Selective and just don’t appreciate their requests for everyone else to back off being ignored. 

A lot of dog owners feel embarrassed when they have to give a caveat or a “but” to their dog’s sociability level – as if that means they’re actually not social at all – but this is where most dogs fit in, and it makes perfect sense.

As humans, most of us are Human Selective. We’ve been taught to not physically harm people we don’t like, but we’re also not expected to become best friends forever with every single person we pass on the street.

And we express mildly aggressive, space-seeking behaviours to pretty much everyone outside of our circle on the daily: looking at our phone and pretending to furiously type when a stranger on the bus starts staring at us like they’re about to talk to us? That raised-eyebrowed tight little smile we give the neighbour as we’re walking up the driveway that says “I’m acknowledging you and reaffirming that we’re neighbours, but please do not engage me in conversation”? Yep. 

Dog Social

These are the dogs who, in general, enjoy interacting with most dogs most of the time. They’re excited for play dates and the dog park, and they give out invitations to interact to just about every dog they see.

These dogs make up a small portion of the dog population, but because they’re so social with others, they generally have few restrictions imposed on them in the outside world, so we see them everywhere. And with the explosion of pets on social media, that phenomenon has just gotten worse. 

In reality, these dogs are fairly rare. And their sociability with other dogs doesn’t always translate to them having good social etiquette. Some dogs who tend to get into scraps at the dog park and are labelled as Dog Aggressive, are actually very much Dog Social, but have no social skills to enable them to communicate with other dogs appropriately, so they’re constantly being rude and are constantly being told off for it. 

Dogs can also have other personality characteristics to describe their play styles, energy levels, likes and dislikes, skills or weaknesses, or physical affectations.

These are important when conducting meetings between dogs, because they allow us to visualise how a potential interaction might play out, and communicate effectively with other dog owners.

But it’s important to understand that these personality descriptions are anthropomorphisations. Anthropomorphising animals isn’t necessarily invalid, but it’s often inaccurate, and tends to ascribe motivations to animal behaviour, which can be detrimental. 

You’ll see us anthropomorphise our dogs when you get to the Special Case Vlogs. We’re not complete buzzkills. As long as we:

  • Are aware that’s what we’re doing
  • Accept that we might be wrong
  • Are happy to change our wrong assessments based on new information/evidence
  • Don’t let the personalities and opinions we’ve ascribed to our dogs blind us to the body language and behavior in front of us (Just one example: “Sparky thinks he’s the boss” can blind us to Sparky being in pain or demonstrating clearly fearful behavior)
  • Don’t let our assessments (“Sparky is an asshole”) negatively affect the way we treat them

If you can do that, by all means, feel free to continue narrating your dog’s thoughts in funny voices. We’re not judging.