Negative experiences with other dogs
The first and probably most obvious danger is that of your dog having negative experiences with other dogs. When we talk about “negative experiences”, most people think of a dog fight. Fights are included in this section, but there are many other ways dogs can have a bad experience with other dogs at the dog park.
These other negative experiences often go unnoticed or misunderstood by dog owners, but they can be as damaging as a full-on attack.
When we take our dog to the dog park, we want them to actively enjoy their time there. The most common negative experience dogs have with others at the dog park is simply being overwhelmed. Dog parks are extremely high stress environments. For some dogs that’s eustress – positive stress, like excitement. For others, it’s distress – negative stress, like fear.
When a distressed dog is placed in a confined – and potentially unfamiliar – area and approached by eustressed dogs, this can make them feel trapped. Often, excited dogs – especially when in a group – simply miss the social signals of others and continue excitedly trying to interact.
This can make some dogs try to escape, or shut down, or ask their human to rescue them.
Dogs attempting to escape an overwhelming situation with other dogs at the dog park will often run away. That can be a magnet for dogs who chase, which can heighten our dog’s fear.
Dogs asking their humans to rescue them will often hide behind their legs, or jump up on them. Both of these behaviours can be mistaken by other dogs and people as play.
Dogs who shut down may hide themselves in a corner and face away from everyone, or appear to be sleeping or staring into space.
And when these behaviours are ignored, inevitably our dogs are forced to resort to aggressive behaviour to gain the space they need. In some cases, they’ll run the gamut of their flight and freeze behaviours first, and in other cases the escalation will happen quickly.
This tends to come as a shock to those eustressed dogs (and their owners), who completely missed all of our dog’s earlier requests for some breathing room.
At best, this gets the excited dogs to back away, in which case our overwhelmed dog has just learned that aggressive behaviour is what is required to protect themselves when other dogs are around. At worst, the excited dogs respond with aggression, and a dog fight erupts. These are often the fights that seem to “come out of nowhere”.
Other common negative experiences include:
- Harassing behaviour from other dogs
- Inappropriate greeting behaviour
- Rough and uninvited play behaviour
- Resource guarding
- Defensive-aggression and competitive-aggression
All of these scenarios send the same message to our dog:
“Other dogs are scary. They overwhelm me, they don’t listen to me, they are threatening, and I don’t have any control over my environment.”
When these experiences are repeated, distressed dogs develop a negative emotional association with other dogs. This can create reactivity and aggression in dogs who were otherwise sociable. And for some young or particularly sensitive dogs, all it takes is one bad experience.
Negative experiences with humans
Just like the dogs at the park are often very excited, and sometimes that excitement causes them to do inappropriate things, the people at the dog park can also get a little over-excited and do inappropriate things.
Dog parks are filled with cute dogs. They’re also typically filled with people who love dogs, and love to interact with them. So, it’s understandable and expected that one of the risks of going to the dog park is that strangers are going to try and love on your dog.
“Risk?” I can hear a lot of voices asking skeptically.
It doesn’t sound particularly harmful, but for dogs who are wary of strangers, or have reactivity towards certain types of people (like men with beards, kids, etc) this is a disaster waiting to happen.
Many owners who bring their dogs to the dog park don’t have knowledge of appropriate human greetings for dogs, and many people greet dogs or try to solicit their attention in ways that can be scary or uncomfortable.
Many owners also do not have an understanding of dog behaviour basics, or positive reinforcement training principles. This can cause our dogs to be inadvertently or directly punished for behaviour they see as acceptable, but which is deemed unacceptable by the humans they are interacting with.
In some cases, humans at the dog park are also distressed. This can be due to fear of dogs, or nerves at navigating the activity of bringing their dog to the dog park in general.
And just like in dogs, distress in humans can manifest as defensive behaviour. Which results in agonistic distance-increasing signals like running, pushing, kneeing, kicking, or yelling. Distress can also manifest as owners physically intervening in healthy play behaviour, sometimes punishing the dog they perceive to be the offender.
If Sparky has negative experiences with humans, it can create reactivity and aggression issues where none were present before.
Negative experiences with other things
Dog parks are rarely located in quiet country pastures. More often than not, dog parks can be found next to busy roads, in bustling cities inhabited by all sorts of people who bring all manner of strange objects with them on their daily commutes. Prams, umbrellas, toys, drones, camera equipment, skateboards, bicycles, etc.
Sometimes, these strange stimuli will make their way inside the dog park. But they don’t have to be inside the dog park to have an effect: trucks driving by, toddlers and their parents walking along the sidewalk, kids running sticks along the park fence, car horns, motorbikes, lawn mowers, neighbourhood cats…
All of these things and more can be noticed by our dogs while they’re in the dog park.
None of these stimuli are particularly unusual. But the danger of dog parks in relation to these stimuli is this: dog parks are large spaces in which your dog is unrestrained, and to a certain extent uncontrollable. For both safety purposes, and successful habituation training purposes, some degree of restraint and control is required when interacting with potentially scary new things.
