We’ve talked about what can go wrong, so now let’s talk about why those things go wrong.
This section is an important tool to help you prepare for a dog park visit as best as possible, and to conduct an accurate risk assessment each time you visit the park so you can make those calculated decisions we spoke about earlier.
Under-socialised dogs and miscommunication
Where conflict arises between dogs in a dog park, it’s usually simply the result of a miscommunication. Someone has played a bit too hard, or mistaken that go-away-now side eye for a chase-me side eye, and things have gotten a little out of hand. Think of all those times you’ve misunderstood someone’s tone of voice, or gotten your wires crossed. The danger of this is especially prominent in a dog park because most of the dogs interacting don’t really know each other. They’re not familiar enough to know each other’s idiosyncrasies, and they read each other wrong. It happens to the best of us.
Sometimes this miscommunication is just a once-off; a genuine misunderstanding, uncharacteristic of both dogs. This doesn’t always mean the conflict will be less serious, but these tense conversations often fizzle out on their own once the offending party realises their mistake.
But sometimes these miscommunications occur more frequently and persistently, and the offending party doesn’t realise their mistake at all.
These types of conflicts are usually the result of under-socialised dogs. They don’t mean to be rude, they just don’t entirely know the rules of this whole dog conversation thing. One minute they’re having a jolly ol’ time, and the next thing they know their conversation partner is snarling in their face.
These dogs are sort of like the awkward kid at the cool kid’s party, trying to make friends and fit in but unknowingly making all kinds of social faux pas and stepping on everyone’s toes. We can usually spot these dogs at the park because they always seem at the centre of all the drama, even though their body language seems to indicate they’re trying to have a good time.
If the under-socialised dog is the type to back respectfully away once they’re faced with an angry playmate, conflicts can usually be avoided. But the main problem with these dogs is that they’ve completely missed the social lead up to the aggression they’re now being faced with. That makes that aggression look like it’s come out of nowhere, and many under-socialised dogs will respond by defending themselves.
High arousal levels
(We introduced the arousal concept in Dog Intros Demystified, so be sure to check that out)
Arousal is related to levels of stress, both eustress and distress. A dog who runs at high arousal or has arousal regulation issues is a dog who essentially has trouble staying appropriately calm, or calming down once they’re stressed.
Bully breeds, like pitties (gosh we love ‘em!), are a classic example of this: they’re never just a little of anything – any owner of a pit bull will tell you that they’re basically either chillin’, or literally screaming, there is no inbetween.
High arousal is often mistaken for high energy. When we treat high arousal dogs like high energy dogs, we add fuel to the fire by giving them excessive exercise, which increases their adrenaline levels. We also create athletes: the more we run them, the fitter they get, and the more exercise they need to satisfy them. And voilà, we’ve created a champion marathon runner who’s built like Arnie, and is in a permanent state of high anxiety. And they’re dragging us down the street toward the park gate, as clouds of smoke billow from our dug-in heels and we try desperately to stay upright.
Dogs in a state of high arousal are like cannonballs in a dog park. They’re so emotionally consumed with their stress, that they’ve lost all their sense of socially appropriate behaviour, spatial awareness, and risk aversion (if they had any to begin with, amirite bully breed and terrier owners?). They’re liable to be generally rude, slam into other dogs and people, injure themselves or others, and throw themselves into any exciting situation they can find. They’re like magnets, inexplicably drawn to any bubbling tension circulating amongst interacting dogs and seem very keen to exacerbate it all.
Most overaroused dogs coming into the dog park start off in eustress, but stress is a sliding scale. These dogs are at high risk of tipping over into distress when presented with just about any trigger.
Think of it like a really drunk person at a party. They’re dancing and jumping around like crazy, yelling and acting a fool… and then maybe they start breaking things, or inserting themselves into social situations that have nothing to do with them so they can egg on a fight. And now suddenly they’re brawling. No one told them to do that stuff, and they weren’t angry – they were having a great time, actually! But at some point, that hyper-excitement spilled over into destruction, and all it took was one wrong look from someone or one suggestion to take it down a notch, and they were primed for violence.
Personality differences
At some stage in our lives, we’ve all been paired up with someone, maybe at work or school, who is just completely different to us. And maybe if we’re in an extra good place personally, we can appreciate those differences and go about our activity peacefully.
But sometimes we can’t help but feel like that person is just so anNOYING UGH! They talk too loud, and they keep touching our arm when they speak to us, and they do this weird thing with their eyes when they think they’re being funny and it’s all just too much, get them away from us!
In these situations, we can act irrationally and, dare we say it, be a little mean. And it’s all very unnecessary; this person didn’t do anything wrong, they didn’t offend us. They’re just… not our type.
Dogs have “types”, too. And when uncomplimentary matches are forced together either by their owners, or by necessities like space or resources, our dogs can also – dare we say it – be a little mean.
Lack of space
Dog park sizes and layouts vary greatly, but one thing they all need to have to avoid conflict is enough space for dogs to escape each other.
To understand what counts as “enough” space, we have to talk a little about canine social space bubbles.
Understanding this concept is pretty easy for us humans, because we have space bubbles as well! A space bubble is essentially the physical distance away from us someone should be for us to feel comfortable. This distance changes based on our relationship to the person in question, because it’s related to our fight, flight or freeze response.
Basically, our brains are telling us that there’s a distance away from us a person should be in order for us to ensure our own safety. Think about the space bubble that makes you feel comfortable when it comes to strangers on the street, acquaintances, friends, the family you like, that one weird family member you don’t like, and intimate partners.
Just like us, dogs have a space bubble that changes depending on their relationships. But unlike us, their space bubbles are much larger. For acquaintances, dogs’ space bubbles are almost ten feet. That means that any time a dog (or pretty much any other animal) that your dog doesn’t know very well, is within a 10ft (3m) radius, they’re officially being that weird guy at the office who stands too close when he talks. They’re probably creeping your dog out.
When assessing a dog park for space, a good rule of thumb is that if more than an aggregate quarter of the space is filled with dogs, it’s probably too crowded. If your dog knows and has good relationships with the majority of those dogs, we can increase that ratio up to about a half, because the space bubbles of most of the dogs involved will be smaller.
This ensures that everyone in the park has enough space to avoid triggering a fight response, as flight still feels like a viable option.
Lack of dog body language understanding
In order to advocate for our dog, and avoid potential trouble, we have to understand what they’re saying.
A lot of dog park conflicts are caused or exacerbated by owners who didn’t truly understand what their dogs were saying to each other. This can lead owners to intervene where they shouldn’t, or not intervene where they should.
Understanding canine communication is the absolute number one, most important, light-it-up-in-neon, louder-for-the-owners-in-the-back necessity for attending the dog park.
Lack of owner attentiveness
We can be so fluent in dog body language that we may as well be a dog, but if we’re not paying attention, all the understanding in the world doesn’t mean squat.
There’s a lot going on at the dog park, and we can be forgiven for being briefly distracted. Being aware of our dog and being aware of our environment is a task and a half. But those distractions should be momentary, and infrequent.
Many owners (particularly the exhausted ones who’ve had a long day week month life at work, who maybe have kids to pick up from school and a sink full of dirty dishes to deal with, and now the completely bonkers teenage cockapoo the family got for Christmas who used to be so cute but is now a MONSTER FROM HELL) take the dog to the dog park because it seems like an activity that doesn’t require much input from them.
Unfortunately, although the dog may be doing most of the exercising, us humans need to do most of the thinking, or else that cute cockapoo monster from hell is going to end up in a world of trouble.
Restrictive tools
We totally get it: keeping the leash on is tempting. Especially for owners of young dogs, inexperienced dogs, exuberant (usually high arousal) dogs, and dogs who don’t have a reliable recall. We don’t want Sparky to run too far away from us, straight into trouble, and have no control.
In general, it’s hard for us dog owners to let go of control. So much about our lives with our dogs – and the training advice we receive – is about control. Controlling their movement, controlling their voice, controlling their wants and needs, controlling the stuff they do and don’t like, controlling their environment….
Being the boss is a lot to worry about. And the dog park represents the ultimate Big Boss Battle of letting go of control.
But keeping leashes on at the dog park is a disaster waiting to happen.
If we hold our dogs back by their leash, we create frustration, which increases their arousal levels. And if other dogs approach our dog while they’re restrained, this can trigger their fight response.
If we leave the leash on but let it drag (usually to “give me something to grab on to” – when realistically our 6ft leash isn’t really going to help much when our dog is half a football field away, and is actually just a security blanket for us), we’re creating a hazard. Many dogs have sustained serious injuries because they were running at full pelt when their leashes snagged on something, got tangled in their legs, or tripped them up.
Size differences

Some little dogs seem to have no idea how small they are. They bravely wrestle with the big dogs as if they were three times their real size.
Some big dogs have no idea how big they are, and they slam into or jump on top of other dogs as if they aren’t giants who weigh 100 pounds.
Sometimes size differences are no big deal. If both the players involved are giving appropriate play signals, are handicapping themselves to even the playing field, and are playing with lots of give and take and plenty of check-ins, then we can just let them do their thing.
But these types of playmates are the exception, not the rule, and until dogs are comfortable enough with each other to play appropriately, large size differences should always be very closely monitored. Or avoided altogether. Injuries incurred when dogs interact can be exaggerated due to the size difference, and can be extremely serious or even fatal – even if injury was never the intention, and/or the conflict was minor and normal.
Under-trained and over-distracted dogs
There are some basic behaviours that all canine dog park attendants need to have pretty solidly under their belt before most types of dog park visits should be allowed.
A reliable recall is one of them. A solid sit/down or other static behaviour that keeps your dog still is another good one to have. A reliable leave it and/or give cue is also a good idea.
This isn’t about proving that you or your dog are “good” enough to use the dog park, or anything like that. We’re not about pitting owners or dogs against each other; dog ownership is hard, it’s complicated, it’s stressful, and it’s not a competition.
These are safety behaviours. Without the safety net of a leash, we need to have some level of ability to control our dog’s movement, so we can help them avoid trouble.
However, that also doesn’t mean that once we train these behaviours in the living room, we can head off to the dog park at peak hour.
A busy dog park is an extremely high difficulty level, and dogs need to have at least a little bit of successful practise performing these behaviours in a similar level.
Inappropriate-aged dogs
Sort of like how we don’t let kids drive cars or drink alcohol, and we don’t take them to a rave, we also don’t take young puppies to dog parks.
Tiny baby dogs are too physically small to safely interact with groups of adult/teenage dogs. And they’re also too mentally and emotionally immature to handle all this excitement. It’s way, WAY too stimulating for them and more likely than not, they’ll become overwhelmed and shut down completely.
For a young brain that’s doing its best to be a sponge and learn all the lessons it can, an experience like that can stay with a puppy into adulthood, and it can inform that dog’s opinions about things like other dogs, or people, or loud noises – or pretty much any other stimuli they perceived at the time of the traumatic event.
In the same vein, elderly dogs are also not good dog park attendees. Many older dogs have pain issues that their owners aren’t even aware of, and that can lower their tolerance for rude behaviour and make them understandably protective of their personal space. Older dogs are more prone to injury when interactions get rowdy, and they can lose their balance in the middle of a thrilling game of chase. Even if our beloved senior citizens seem keen to run with the big dogs, they are often physically and emotionally less capable than they think they are, and we need to protect them.
