Here are solutions to some house training woes. These solutions might get a little creative, but you’ll notice that the basic strategy is always, always the same:
Physically prevent accidents, provide lots of opportunities to eliminate in the right place, and reward the crap out of her when she does.
Real talk: most of the potty training troubles I hear about happen because the dog owner is not following the basic strategy.
So maybe run through this course again real quick, analyze your actions and make sure they’re really dialed in.
Most problems clear up when you commit to this plan and stick to it with consistency, patience, and repetition.
Puppy Survival School/All-Access Pass members: feel free to post any questions on the forums.
1. My dog will not go potty when I’m around/My dog will not go potty on leash.
There’s a good chance that someone, maybe in your dog’s previous home, punished him for eliminating in the wrong place. Now he’s learned that it’s dangerous to go in the presence of people.
Or maybe he’s just modest? Who knows.
Now Sparky has to get to know and trust you, and learn that you’re a reasonable person who is not going to go all Hulk Smash because of Sparky’s basic bodily functions.
In the meantime, give him enough space that he feels comfortable relieving himself.
If you have a fenced yard, set him loose while you supervise discreetly from the door. Maybe even stay inside and watch from the window.
I know the course recommends taking your pup directly to the area you want them to use as their bathroom. But if your dog refuses to go in your presence, the priority is just to get him to go in the yard at all. As he becomes comfortable with you, you can narrow down his bathroom area.
If you don’t have a fenced yard, use a longline. For your dog’s bathroom area, choose a place you can let the leash extend a good distance.
Be as non-threatening as possible: crouch down and turn away so that you’re not directly facing him, and pretend not to watch. Play with your phone, gaze thoughtfully off into the sunset, etc.
When he goes, don’t praise or make any movements/sounds – you don’t want to scare him away. Wait for him to finish, then bring him some super-high-value treats.
2. My dog refuses to eliminate outdoors.
Will she eliminate in your presence indoors? If not, this might actually be the previous problem. Otherwise, maybe the weather sucks. Or maybe it’s a matter of surface preference: she’s in the habit of going on an indoor surface. Here are three solutions, in order of what you should try first:
A. If she will eliminate on newspapers or pee pads, take a few sheets outside. Reward her for eliminating on them. Over a couple weeks, wean her off them by gradually reducing the sheet area. If you start with three sheets, work your way down to two, then one, then half a sheet, then a quarter sheet.
B. If that’s not the solution, than it might be a matter of being more stubborn than your dog. After she’s had some water, give it a few minutes then take her outside. Wait 15-20 minutes. If she doesn’t go, bring her inside and hold on to her. If she’s small enough, carry her. If not, hold her by the collar. Do not take your eyes off her and Do. Not. Let. Go. Wait 15 minutes. Go back outside. Repeat this as long as it takes. Maybe enlist your family members to take turns holding her.
When she finally “breaks,” reward the everloving crap out of that dog. Whole fistfuls of real chicken, beef, or hot dog bits! Real-life rewards out the wazoo! The longer it took for her to break, the bigger the reward must be.
C. If the weather is truly horrendous, some dogs will flat out refuse to step one dainty paw outside. It might be easier on everyone to use an indoor natural dog potty or pee pads. You can wean her off the pee pads when spring returns.
3. My dog eliminates outside, but pees again as soon as we come in.
You might not be giving her enough time to finish her business. Dogs will often go once, wander around, and go again. So when she goes the first time, don’t come right back in. This is why it’s good to take a walk after a potty break. It gives her more time to completely empty herself.
When you bring this dog back inside, keep her on a leash or hold her collar for a while, so you can interrupt any squatting or leg-lifting. As long as you reward her often and consistently enough for good behavior and interrupt all bad behavior, she’ll figure out that it’s in her best interest to make all her deposits outside.
4. My dog will eliminate in the appropriate area just fine, but he doesn’t get the concept of GETTING to the appropriate area.
So your dog is developing the habit of eliminating in the backyard. Awesome! But he has an accident in the house if you don’t take him there yourself. He doesn’t understand the path to the bathroom. Here’s how to teach him (this requires your dog to have a decent understanding of where the bathroom is and a “go potty” cue).
At his regularly scheduled bathroom break, put him on leash and walk him right up to the door like usual. Open the door, but don’t step outside yourself – instead of leading him out, you want him to decide to do it himself. If he doesn’t walk right out, just stand there in the door frame with the leash held close, and wait. When he steps outside, mark/reward, and say your potty cue as you continue towards the bathroom area.
Next time, stop a couple steps back from the door. As he takes the first steps toward it, mark/reward, then head out, saying your potty cue. The next time, stop a few more steps back from the door, and so on.
5. My dog eliminates in his crate.
This is probably a sign that you’re crating him too long. Start with shorter confinements and more bathroom trips. But if your dog seems to PREFER eliminating in the crate, you might have ended up with one of those unfortunate dogs who were conditioned to soil their living space. In that case, use a dog room instead of a crate. You want to recondition your dog to keep his bed clean. The dog room, with one end for living space and one end for bathroom space, helps facilitate this.
As your dog develops the habit of eliminating outdoors (or in his indoor dog potty), you can reintroduce the crate as a management tool, if you want.
6. When I’m home, I take my puppy to the bathroom every hour, like you said. She goes, but then she has an accident in the house 30 minutes later.
Your puppy is telling you how often she needs to go. Every hour was a good place to start until you got to know her. Now you know her! Take her out every 30 minutes.
7. I read [in this course or elsewhere] that my dog should be able to hold for X amount of time. But she doesn’t. How do I know if she can’t hold it anymore or if she’s just choosing not to?
Science has not yet given us a way to read dogs’ minds, so this is a moot point. A distinction without a difference. “Can she hold it” vs “will she hold it” is irrelevant. All that matters is that she’s not holding it. When some people ask this question, I get the feeling that they’re looking for a reason to justify their desire to teach the little rapscallion a lesson. This dog can hold it just fine, she’s just trying to screw with me!
You don’t decide the right length of time between bathroom breaks. Your dog does. Your dog isn’t screwing with you – she’s communicating her needs. You want your dog to trust you? That’s a two-way street. Trust that she will tell you her truth, if only you will listen.
8. Alas! My dog has had many accidents indoors. Is it too late for us?
It’s never too late, buttercup.
First, you gotta do some hardcore cleanup. Any pee or poo odor that remains will encourage Sparky to continue to eliminate there. Remove any urine-soaked bedding. Get some enzyme-based cleaner and scrub everything real good. It’s harder to remove all traces from carpeting, so if possible, make carpeted areas completely off-limits from now on.
Here’s a nifty hack: Since dogs are naturally averse to eating and pooping in the same spot, turn all his usual accident spots into feeding spots. Clean the area first, of course, then scatter treats there on a regular basis. Feed his meals there.
Beyond that, it’s about doubling down on the basic strategy. You’ll have to put a bit more effort into it since you’re not just creating good habits, you’re reversing bad ones. But yeah, it is absolutely possible to house train this dog.
9. I have a unique house training problem.
The details of each situation may vary, but the treatment always follows the basic strategy. Examples:
“My dog pees on my bed when I’m not home.”
Well, why is your dog given free access to your bed when you’re not home, silly head? Manage, manage, manage.
“My dog refuses to eliminate anywhere EXCEPT the crate.”
Now there’s an interesting plot twist. Try using a dog room in reverse: put the pee pads inside the crate, and a living area in the other end. Wean the dog off the pee pads as described in problem 2.
“My puppy potties just fine during the day, but refuses to go at night.”
Puppies often initiate Hyper Attack Puppy mode at bedtime, and their daytime good behavior goes out the window. He should get over it as he gets older. Cut off his water access 30 minutes before you anticipate his shenanigans starting. Then manage, manage, manage.
“My dog will only pee on my husband’s left gym shoe.”
If your husband is willing to sacrifice his left gym shoe, wean the dog off it by placing it in the desired bathroom area. Otherwise, remove access to the shoe. Then out-stubborn your dog as described in problem 2.
