How to reduce pulling without training

Practical Leash Manners: Loose Leash Walking STRATEGY How to reduce pulling without training

Front clip harnesses (and other no-pull tools)

For a temporary way to gain more control of your dog while you work on training leash manners, we recommend front clip harnesses. They work in two ways:

  1. When the dog pulls, the harness gets pulled to the side, which physically limits the amount of force the dog can exert against the leash.
  2. It makes pulling uncomfortable. This discomfort motivates (some, not all) dogs to pull less. If you want to get all technical, it’s in the negative punishment quadrant of operant conditioning: removing something (discomfort) to reduce the frequency of a behavior (pulling).

Other tools designed to reduce pulling include but are not limited to:

  • Prong collars
  • Choke chains
  • Head halters (Gentle Leaders)
  • Any collar or slip lead positioned high on the dog’s neck, just behind the ears

All of these, including front clips, are aversive. An aversive is something unpleasant (or the threat of something unpleasant) used to correct an unwanted behavior. There are no anti-pulling collars/harnesses that are not aversive.

In my experience, Y-shaped front clips are the least aversive and least likely to cause injury, which is why I recommend them in situations where the owner struggles to control their dog.

To be clear, we believe aversives aren’t good for canine welfare or the dog-human bond, so we limit their presence in our training as much as possible. But if you physically cannot control your dog, ya gotta do what ya gotta do.

A note on prong collars:

I have used these myself, and they ARE effective at reducing pulling when the dog is wearing them. Whether dogs find them painful or just really uncomfortable, it’s clear that the sensation they create is highly aversive. Otherwise, it wouldn’t be such an effective punisher.

I no longer use these collars and don’t recommend them to our students, but what if you’re already using a prong collar? That’s cool. If they help you feel safer and prevent your dog from dragging you into traffic, you can absolutely work through this program with your prong collar.

Our goal is to establish better leash behavior via training and reduce our reliance on any tool, whether front clips or prong collars.

Picking the right front clip harness

Look for one with a y-shaped front, like this:

The Front Range harness

Avoid harnesses with a horizontal front strap that crosses the shoulders, like this:

The Easy Walk harness

We like these front-clip harnesses:

  • The Balance Harness by Blue-9 (please note that this is Balance Harness, brand name, not just “a balance harness.”)
  • The Front Range Harness by Ruffwear (this is the green harness that River’s modeling)
  • The Flagline Harness by Ruffwear
  • The Journey Harness or Journey Air Harness by Kurgo

Because of the horizontal strap, we don’t recommend:

  • The Easy Walk Harness by Petsafe
  • The Sense-Ation Harness by Softouch Concepts
  • The Walk About Harness by Kurgo

Exercise and enrichment at home

Check out these links to get some ideas: