How to introduce a shy puppy to people

Socialization Tutorials How to introduce a shy puppy to people

Is your puppy shy, fearful, or hesitant to approach people? This video will teach you what to do, and there are more tips below the video.

Key takeaways from the video:

Don’t have people handfeed a shy/fearful puppy. If a dog is afraid to come near you, but you hold out a piece of food, his hunger might override his fear for a moment. He might walk up to you and take the treat. But once he eats it, he’s now just standing very close to a scary person! Holy crap!

If this happens, in the best case scenario he’ll experience a jolt of fear. Worst case scenario, he’ll bite you to defend himself.

(There are exceptions – handfeeding can work with some dogs. But let’s err on the side of good dog training principles)

Two things to do instead of handfeeding

Have your visitors toss treats away from themselves. This creates a double helping of good feelings: the puppy gets a treat, and they also get distance from the scary person, which creates a feeling of relief.

Do something the puppy enjoys while your visitors hang out nearby. In the session with Misty, Erin did lots of training with her, which Misty loves. This counts as good passive socialization with strangers: I’m sitting right there, so Misty’s learning to associate my presence with good things.

How to play the treat-tossing game

These instructions are based on the Treat-Retreat exercise developed by Suzanne Clothier.

Level one

Have your guest sit on the floor, if possible. A chair is also okay. Give them a container of high value treats. They should start by positioning their bodies facing away from the puppy.

Ask them not to make eye contact or speak loudly. If the puppy approaches them, they should:

  • Not look at the puppy or try to touch them
  • Remain fairly still, and breathe normally. (This is an important detail; people sometimes interpret “stay still” to mean “freeze in place and hold your breath.” But freezing in place and holding your breath is a warning behavior in dog speak.)

Have them toss the treat behind the puppy, using an underhand throw (overhead can look threatening). If the puppy is not scared of hearing their voice, they can make a kissy noise or say the puppy’s name to get their attention before the throw.

Keep each session to about three minutes, or longer if the puppy stays engaged and keeps approaching.

How to level up

Let your puppy control the pace of the interaction. To figure out when you can move to the next level of this exercise, watch Sparky’s body language.

Signs you can level up

These will make more sense if you take Understanding Your Puppy and/or Dog Speak 101)

Watch for at least two of the following:

  • The dog’s stance becomes neutral or relaxed while waiting for the treat toss; not placing all their weight on their back feet like Misty did (pictured below)
  • The puppy is faster to approach the person
  • They come up to sniff the person’s clothing or body (not just sniffing the ground for treats)
  • Their facial expression, tail, and ears become more relaxed
  • They don’t flinch or dart away upon every movement the person makes
No touching allowed: Misty’s hind feet are planted as far back as possible, to make a quick escape. She’s not ready to be friends

The next levels

Level 2: Instead of tossing the treat away, toss it on the ground between the person and the dog.
Level 3: Offer the pup a treat out of their flat, open palm.

When is it okay to touch the dog?

With Misty, I didn’t try to touch her until our second meeting. We didn’t do treat tossing this time. I just entered the play area, careful to keep my body sideways to her, and sat on the floor. She came up to sniff me. I talked gently while she did.

Then I just watched while she played with Erin. Next time she approached me, I held up my hand for her to sniff (still sideways, not reaching toward her)

On the third approach, I gave her a brief, light pet on her shoulder.

The touching phase should be separate from the treat-throwing phase. We don’t want to put the dog in the uncomfortable position of tolerating petting in order to earn a treat.

So after you’ve made some progress with treat throwing, set the treats aside. When the puppy approaches with neutral or relaxed body language, the person can conduct a consent test. We have a lesson on consent tests, but basically:

Give the dog a light scritch on the side or shoulder, then stop, and see how they respond. If the dog moves toward the person for more, great! They can keep petting. If the dog moves away, flinches, or freezes, no more petting.

Dos and don’ts when you try petting for the first time:

Do:

  • Face sideways
  • Sit or kneel on the floor, if possible
  • Touch the shoulder or sides
  • Stroke or scratch gently

Don’t:

  • Reach over their head
  • Learn over them
  • Touch the head, face, or belly

How long does this take?

I’m going to give you everyone’s favorite infuriating answer: it depends. Sometimes, you can go from treat tossing to cuddling in one meeting. Sometimes it takes a few days of level-one treat tossing to see the slightest hint of progress.

And your puppy may not ever want strangers to pet them, and that’s okay! I don’t like to socialize with every stranger I meet, either. Hazel and River are grown ups now, and Hazel enjoys being petted by new people we meet on the street River, ever the introvert, does not want strangers to touch her. She has to get to know and like someone before she wants pats.