The fearful puppy

So you watched the Fearful Puppy video and decided that yes indeed, your puppy shows signs of being fearful. What now?

What you need to know about shy/fearful puppies

Standard socialization methods may do more harm than good. For instance, puppy classes are a great way to socialize “normal” puppies, but if your pup spends every class being terrified, he’ll only learn to be more afraid. And in some cases, having strangers feed treats may be too scary.

Socializing a normal puppy consists of casually introducing them to new things and making it into a fun time, but socializing the shy or fearful puppy is all about desensitizing them to things, which takes more time and patience.

Desensitization: exposing the pup to New Things/Scary Things in doses that are tiny enough that they don’t react negatively.

Socialization Guidelines

Let the puppy determine the pace of the experience. This is necessary for all puppies, but it’s critical for fearful puppies. Sparky needs to know that he can say “no” to an experience (meeting a stranger, walking on a scary surface, etc), and you will respect his wishes. Basically, he needs to know he can trust you. If the puppy feels like he has no control over whether he interacts with a scary thing, he will grow up to be MORE fearful or aggressive.

Find situations that your pup is comfortable in, and focus a lot of your efforts there. I initially started trying to socialize River to the outside world in my neighborhood, but she was always afraid there. Too afraid to socialize/desensitize effectively. There were no locations at which she felt safe. But the park was another story. She was generally more relaxed, and there were lots of out-of-the-way areas where she felt happy and unworried where we could set up our home base.

Watch River’s Socialization Vlogs. They’re all about socializing the more nervous puppy.

Shy vs. Fearful: They require two different approaches

For our purposes today, we’re gonna use two classifications: Shy, and Fearful.

A quick test:

Your puppy is Shy if, upon encountering a new person or dog:

  • He hides or barks at first, but warms up and approaches within ten minutes, sniffing them and wagging his tail.
  • He will eat high-value treats that are handed to him, or tossed to him, by a stranger

Your Puppy is Fearful if, upon encountering a new person or dog:

  • He hides or barks, and does not warm up. His behavior worsens- either he shuts down further, tries to escape, or the growling and barking increases
  • He will not eat high-value treats that are handed to him, or tossed to him, by a stranger

Recommendations for the Shy puppy

Puppy socialization classes. Find one that will allow you and Sparky to sit in a “shy puppy” area until he warms up. Never force a shy puppy into a group of puppies.

Have LOTS of one-on-one meetings with people. Invite one or two friends to your house at a time, instead of inviting a bunch of people at a time.

Have LOTS of people hand or toss your puppy treats.

In addition, do lots of non-greeting adventures where you play the Observation Game.

Do not let people pet the puppy unless the puppy goes up and touches them, with tail wagging.

My approach with River: upon arriving in public places, River was often overwhelmed and would bark at people. So we’d play the Observation Game for a while. This usually built her confidence up enough to approach people, who would feed her treats, and pet her if she indicated it was okay.

Recommendations for the Fearful puppy

The strategy becomes more about observing from a distance, rather than interacting with tons of people and dogs. So:

Do not attend socialization classes. They’ll do more harm than good.

Play the Observation Game a lot. Eat, sleep, and breathe the Observation Game.

If Sparky is too afraid to concentrate out in public, play the Observation Game at home: invite friends to your home, hand them a beer, put them in front of the TV and tell them to ignore the puppy, and have the puppy Observe them.

Take Sparky on lots of outings to places where there are no humans or dogs. The forest, a big empty field, etc. Sparky needs a chance to explore and have fun out in the world with no “threat” of social interaction.

Do private training sessions with a good, reward-based dog trainer, if at all possible. This level of fear is highly abnormal in puppies, and you’ll need professional guidance for best results.