Teaching calm behavior around your other dog/cat: a training exercise

Your Puppy & Your Other Pets Your Puppy and Your Dog Teaching calm behavior around your other dog/cat: a training exercise

Does your puppy harass your cat or older dog? This tutorial will help. In this video, Hazel’s learning to exist calmly near Violet the cat without bothering him. There’s more info under the video, so be sure to read that, too.

What to do first:

Make sure your puppy’s exercise/mental stimulation/enrichment needs are met. It’s normal for puppies to want to harass and chomp on your other pets – puppies are super annoying that way. But you can keep the harassment to a minimum by doing your Foundation course homework and giving Chomper a couple hours a day of exploration, play, socialization, learning, and working for his food. He’ll be less likely to take his boredom out on the cat. See these relevant lessons:

For best results:

For this exercise to go as well as possible, it helps if your puppy has already had some practice with the following:

How to do this exercise:

Do this when your pup is in a relatively chill mood. Avoid attempting it when he’s in Hyper Attack Mode.

Step one

Put Chomper on leash, and bring him and the other pet (for tutorial purposes, let’s use an imaginary cat named Puff) into the same area. Work at a distance where the puppy is aware of the cat, but not going nuts. For some puppies, like Hazel in the video, this may mean the cat can be only a couple feet away on the couch. For other puppies, Puff may need to be allllll the way down the hall with a baby gate between them. Either way is perfectly fine. Do what you need to do to set your pup up for success.

Important: Unlike our setup in the video, I don’t recommend holding your cat still and forcing her to be near the pup. The cat should be free to come and go as she pleases. (We only held our cat Violet still for a video demonstration, because it turned out to be hard to capture this exercise on video organically)

If your other pet is a dog: You want that dog to be “boring” and not looking at the puppy. Movement and eye contact might be too exciting for the puppy at this stage. Have an assistant keep the other dog nice and calm by having them sit or lie down for treats.

Step two

Using real chicken or other high value treat, mark and reward any and all good behavior from the pup. Good behavior includes:

  • Sitting
  • Lying down
  • Sniffing the cat without attacking her
  • Looking away from the cat to you
  • Walking away from the cat
  • Trying to go for the toy instead of the cat
  • Not going after the cat when the cat runs away, makes a sudden move, or makes a noise

This is basically a concentrated version of the catch and reward concept.

Maintain a high rate of reinforcement. At this stage, a mark/reward should be happening about every three seconds. Watch the video carefully, and notice all the little moments of good behavior that I SHOULD have mark/rewarded Hazel for but didn’t. (Bad dog trainer! Maybe the environment was too distracting for me?)

If you can’t mark/reward every few seconds because the pup is not showing good behaviors, see the troubleshooting section below.

End the session after one or two minutes. Separate the pets, and then immediately direct the puppy into some fun game like tug of war.

Using toys instead of, or in addition to, food

Some puppies find play to be a better reward for this than food. They want to roughhouse with Puff, after all. Play gives them an appropriate outlet for their roughhousing urges. A plush toy on a string makes a good cat substitute. Watch how I do this with Hazel in the video.

Leveling up

When you can get through a whole two-minute session without Chomper lunging at Puff, you can level up. Over multiple sessions, gradually bring the pets closer to each other.

If Chomper gets his teeth on the cat

Gently hold Chomper back and “be boring” for a few seconds. The message is: “if I go after the cat, fun times end.” Then redirect him – make funny noises, call his name, tease him with a toy, etc. Whatever works to get his attention back on you. The instant he shows good behavior, mark/reward.

Troubleshooting

  1. Chomper will not stop going after Puff, and does not exhibit any of the “good behaviors:”

You might be working too close to Puff. Increase the distance enough that Chomper gets his brain back and can listen to you. You might need to put up a visual barrier so Chomper is aware the other animal is there, but can’t see them.

It’s also possible Chomper is getting too jazzed up and entering Hyper Attack Mode. You may need to try again later, after meeting some of his needs as explained in this lesson.

2. There aren’t enough good behaviors happening to mark/reward every few seconds:

Try “splitting your criteria” – breaking the good behaviors into tinier components. For example, instead of waiting for Chomper to look away from the cat, mark/reward as soon as he looks in the cat’s direction without going after her. (The Observation Game might be helpful).

You can also do multiple mark/rewards for one behavior. You don’t need to mark/reward Chomper when he sits and then wait for another behavior to reward – like in the video, I mark/reward Hazel continuously for as long as she’s sitting.

If splitting criteria doesn’t work, follow the advice for troubleshooting point 1.