UPDATE: In addition to the information below, we now have a separate workshop replay that goes into much more detail and answers common questions about this process. Check it out: Help! I’m a Prisoner in My Own Home
Does your puppy freak out when you leave his sight for two seconds? Are you worried that something’s wrong with him? Or that you’re going to be a prisoner in your own home forever?
Don’t worry – that behavior is a totally normal part of puppy development. In fact, from your puppy’s perspective, being alone is what’s weird.
It makes sense if you think about it: for your puppy’s whole life before you got him he probably never spent a single moment alone. He’s always had his mom, littermates, and previous human caretakers around. Being alone is a totally foreign concept!
The younger they are, the more likely they are to cry when alone. In the eight-to-twelve week range, puppies are in their exploratory period. This is when they leave the “den,” or whelping box, and start investigating the world around them, and getting into trouble. To make sure they survive this time in their lives, nature gave them a built-in alarm system: if they ever find themselves stuck, or alone, or lost, their instinct is to scream bloody murder and wait for mom to locate them.
And guess who “mom” is now? That’s right, it’s you!
Being in their crate or pen, separated from people, can also just be plain frustrating.
When you put them in their crate and then go off and cook dinner or attempt to take a shower, they can still hear you, and they want to be involved in whatever it is you’re doing. It’s almost like a case of FOMO – fear of missing out. Puppies have a very low tolerance for frustration in general. It’s something they have to learn as they mature.
So this is a normal time in a puppy’s development, and they need to be properly supported during this time. They shouldn’t be made to cry it out, or punished for crying.
Instead, we have to help them adapt to the weird human household they’ve found themselves in. We can help them learn that being alone is okay, and they aren’t going to die (or miss out on something super exciting) just because you’ve left their sight for two seconds.
We do this by slowly desensitizing them to being alone.
Desensitization: exposing the puppy to the trigger (which, in this case, is being separate from people) in doses that are small enough not to set off the crying/whining, letting the puppy realize “hey, this isn’t so bad!” and gradually increasing the “dose” of being alone. This process builds their confidence as well as their frustration-tolerance.
Preventative alone training
Even if alone-time whining isn’t an issue for you, you should still work on this training. Teaching puppies how to be alone may* help prevent separation-related behavior problems when they’re adults.
See, the way a lot of us spend the early days with our new dogs sets them up to be blindsided by what normal life will be like.
Typical scenario: a family adopts a dog at the beginning of a weekend or summer break (or during a pandemic) so they can spend as much time with her as possible. Sparky gets lavished with constant attention, and gets used to spending all day with her humans.
And then Monday comes. Or lockdown ends. The household goes back to school and jobs and real life.
Sparky goes from never spending a moment alone to spending hours alone. Not all dogs can handle such a drastic shift, and may bark excessively or act destructively.
*Can you truly prevent or cause separation anxiety?
Many dog trainers (including me, in the original edition of this lesson!) have said that if you don’t properly prepare your puppy for being alone, it can cause separation anxiety (SA) when they’re adults. Insinuating that if your dog DOES develop SA, it’s kinda your fault. However, upon further research, we realized it’s a lot less black and white than that.
The causes of separation anxiety are not fully known, so it would be impossible to say for sure that any specific action you take can “prevent” or “cause” SA, wouldn’t it? What we do know is that it’s probably a complex blend of nature and nurture, heavy on the nature side. True separation anxiety is a disorder, after all.
Puppy parents, breathe a little easier: your pup’s fate in this regard is not resting fully on your shoulders and whether or not you do alone training exactly right. That would be like saying my parents could’ve prevented my ADHD from developing, if only they’d done a specific set of training exercises.
So rather than talking about preventing or causing SA, it’s better to think in terms of what you can do to optimize your puppy for alone time success (a phrase I took from Malena DeMartini, a canine SA expert). Giving them the tools they need to handle whatever life, and genetics, throws at them. The training in this section will help with that.
See the next lesson for training details.
