Puppy attacks out of nowhere

Biting SPECIFIC SCENARIOS Puppy attacks out of nowhere

The scenario:

You and Sparky are hanging out in the same area but not interacting. Maybe you’re watching TV on the couch or cooking dinner in the kitchen. Sparky’s happily minding her own business. Suddenly, totally out of nowhere, she launches at you! She starts jumping and biting. The biting skips the gentle level and goes straight to the “holy &*#$ that HURTS” level.

What this means:

It’s usually social play behavior. Sparky may be getting bored and lonely, so she’s seeking interaction with her new family. The fact that she’s biting hard indicates there’s probably a touch of overtiredness or overarousal in the mix. We’re at or approaching Hyper Attack Mode.

But look on the bright side: your puppy wants to engage with you. That’s a good start for building a bond. You just gotta help her refine her behavior into less painful types of engagement.

Puppy parents may not see this “shark attack” behavior get into full swing until puppy reaches 4-5 months old. Not all puppies develop it – some are more predisposed to it than others.

But if Sparky’s biting was manageable at age 2-3 months and then gets worse at 4 months? Yep, that’s normal. Sparky is still at an age where they’re programmed to face the world teeth first, but now they have more strength and stamina than they used to.

If it’s managed properly and not reinforced, the shark attacks taper off in adolescence.

Some puppies may also do this to tell you they need to go to the bathroom. If you think that’s what’s happening, let us know on the forums and we can chat about it.

More on this behavior:

This is how puppies start out initiating play with their littermates. Mostly random chomping, very little actual play invitation body language.

They will continue to play this way with the adult dogs in their lives.

Behaviorally-sound adult dogs are pretty tolerant of puppy nonsense, but if it gets to be too much or too painful, they will not reinforce it by playing back. They start teaching puppies the rules of dog play, which is that play invitations must be given via ritualized body language, and play can only start if the invitee responds in kind.

(More on this in Dog Introductions Demystified if you want to get into the fascinating details of canine play language)

Here’s a video where we answered a member’s question on this topic. Watch it and then scroll down to read the rest of the lesson.

Make sure your foundation is solid

Are you playing Puppy Taming and reinforcing the crap out of a default sit?

This gives Sparky a better way to ask for what she needs. Work on this diligently enough and she should start “sitting at you” when she wants something, instead of her current default approach of sneak attacking.

Does your puppy know at least one cued skill?

A sit on cue works well, but so do a lot of others like hand targeting, down, or spin. This lets you cue an incompatible alternative behavior (meaning Sparky can’t chew on you if he’s sitting) when he bites. See Baby Obedience.

Are you catching and rewarding behavior you like?

Reward your puppy for doing nothing and entertaining himself whenever possible.

How’s your management setup? Crates are great, but unless you enjoy suffering, they’re not enough.

Do you have a way to quickly put a barrier (baby gate, folding table, large flat cardboard box, sofa, exercise pen, etc) between you?

Remember River and Hazel’s casual living room puppy containment area from the management lesson?

In a perfect world, you’ll have something like that. Either use an opened-up exercise pen to section off one large area of your home, or use baby gates to create separate areas of your home so you can easily move between areas but your puppy can’t follow.

Have you been building their tolerance for physical separation by teaching them to be alone?

Also in a perfect world, you’d be getting your puppy used to staying in their large confinement area starting in week one, so they aren’t bothered when you walk out of it.

If you didn’t start in week one? That’s okay! Much like planting a tree, the second best time to start is today.

Has Sparky been getting enough exercise, mental stimulation and socialization adventures lately?

If the random attacks increase as the puppy gets older, a contributing factor could be that their enrichment needs have increased with age and the amount they used to get isn’t cutting it anymore.

Be proactive and get ahead of the behavior

The more the puppy practices this behavior, the more of a habit it becomes. So the best way to deal with it is by stopping it before it starts. Either by:

  1. Management that completely prevents the attack sequence, or
  2. Interrupting the attack sequence before the biting part.

Are there patterns to the random attacks? Does it happen:

  • At a certain time of day?
  • When you’re outside?
  • When you are doing a specific activity? Sitting on the floor, cooking dinner, as soon as you sit on the couch, etc.
  • After Sparky has done a specific activity?
  • After Sparky has NOT done a specific activity? Like missing out on exercise that day.
  • After Sparky has been awake and active for a certain amount of time?
  • After a meal? Before a meal?

If you’re not sure, start writing down every time it happens. Make a note of:

-The time of day
-What you and Sparky were doing right before
-How long it had been since his last nap
-Anything else that was happening in the immediate area at the time

If you start seeing patterns, you’ll start picking up on things that might be triggering the behavior. Then you can start preempting it by managing or initiating an acceptable activity.

For example, if it happens every evening around the same time, plan on incorporating a 3-2-1 Chill Out Routine in the evenings.

If it happens right before naptime, start putting him in his management setup.

If it happens as soon as you sit down on the couch, call him to you before you sit, ask HIM to sit while you sit down, and give him a treat or gentle petting if he enjoys that.

Is it really happening out of nowhere?

Sometimes, yes – puppies may go bananas with no warning. They truly are tiny agents of chaos.

But they usually give subtle warnings. Either intentionally with a clumsy play invitation or unintentionally with a “tell” like sighing dramatically and looking around the room for mischief to get into, or getting up and stretching, or marching around with their tail curled high over their back.

And because by the very nature of this scenario, it’s almost always happening when you aren’t paying attention, then you would never notice a subtle warning or play invitation anyway. So of course it seems “out of nowhere.”

Make it a project this week to pay more attention to what your puppy is doing when you aren’t actively engaging with him.

You’ll probably notice that the attack is not a single behavior, but a sequence of behaviors that happen as a response to a triggering event.

Note: I don’t mean “triggering” to mean distressing, I just mean whatever happens that causes the behavior to start. In dog training, we call this an antecedent or a cue.

If the attacks happen at 5:05pm every day, 5:05pm is the trigger/antecedent. If they happen after Sparky finishes his bully stick, then finishing the bully stick is the trigger/antecedent.

Antecedents are not always obvious external factors; they can seem to be more of an internal experience for the dog, like being bored or restless or hungry. It might take some curiosity and empathy on your part to figure it out, but there’s always an antecedent.

Notice any play invitations and reward the crap out of them. We need to encourage them to develop their fledgling social skills. See: what you need to know about play behavior.

And when you’re doing something that takes up your focus so you can’t watch your puppy?

Like cooking, changing your baby’s diaper, taking online courses, decompressing from your day by shutting off your brain and scrolling the internet, etc?

Then the puppy shouldn’t be wandering around unsupervised and uncontained, anyway. They might chew up something they shouldn’t or pee where they shouldn’t.

If Sparky cries when kept behind a barrier, you can start killing three birds with one stone: prevent bitey attacks while teaching your puppy to be alone and rewarding them for doing nothing. While you watch your online course or cook dinner, put them in their pen or behind a baby gate and toss treats to them periodically.

And yes, I get it. Being proactive about catching the behavior early in the sequence (before the biting part) and consistent about management takes a lot of energy! It’s not always possible in real life. Just do your best.

What is Reward to Punish?

Mentioned by Erin in the video. RTP is a counterintuitive method where you give the dog something good (like a treat) to get an unwanted behavior to stop. Like tossing treats when the puppy bites, or scattering treats on the floor to get them to stop excitement barking when you’re preparing to take them on a walk.

To get nerdy, this is a case when the word “reward” is not interchangeable with “reinforcer,” because it doesn’t actually reinforce (aka increase) the targeted behavior.

Put simply, RTP gets the dog doing a different behavior -one we like- that we can then further reinforce and build upon.

Put slightly less simply, RTP works when the reward does not match up with the dog’s motivation for doing the unwanted behavior in the first place.

In other words, the reward does not serve the function of the behavior.

The dog barking at the door when you say “walkies!” isn’t barking because she wants treats, she wants to go outside! She might still eat the treats you toss her to get her to shut up, because hey, treats are nice, but it won’t cause her to bark more in the future because it doesn’t fit the function.

What to do in the moment

When Sparky launches at you, calmly remove her teeth from your skin. You may say “no” or “ah ah” to help interrupt the behavior if you wish, or you can just not react verbally at all.

Then disengage as you step through/over the nearest baby gate or exit the puppy confinement zone. If that isn’t possible, take her to her crate/confinement area.

Congratulations! You have now turned this instance of biting into a boring experience, to add to what should be an ever-growing pile of “biting is boring” experiences.

If you have literally no way of creating a physical barrier, act as boring as possible while keeping her teeth as far from you as possible, and skip ahead to the treat thing.

(But also ask yourself why you have literally no way of creating a physical barrier and consider how you might change that)

So with some physical separation, you now have a brief cushion of time separating the two of you from the unpleasantness of five seconds ago, and you can consider what your next move will be.

And that could just be the end of it. Feel like it’s time for an enforced nap? Sure! Sparky can hang out in his crate with a chew for a while. You have our blessing to sometimes just put the tiny demon away when you cannot deal. Especially if you’re getting angry. Taking a moment (or three) to breathe and calm down serves both of you better than forcing a training interaction that won’t go well.

Or you could do some training and treat tossing instead, as described in the video above.

Or you can get out the high value toy and start a game.

“What if this happens when we’re out in the yard and I can’t easily march him all the way inside to his confinement area?”

That’s why you always take a pocketful of treats and/or your high value tug toy with you into the yard, so you can redirect or preempt as needed.

“But if I redirect my puppy with food or toys, won’t she learn that all she has to do is bite me and then she’ll get rewarded?”

Great question! A potential risk of this type of training is the creation of an unwanted behavior chain, as mentioned in the video above.

See, we want to teach the dog that sitting on cue results in a treat. But clever pups might figure out that biting results in a sit cue, which results in a treat. For dogs to learn this, the pattern must be repeated many times, consistently over time.

So if you just have to do it occasionally when management and proactivity fails? Not a problem. But if it becomes your default response? Yeah, it might become a problem.

This is why it’s important to intervene before the biting happens as much as possible.

Which requires you to recognize the attack behavior for what it is: a sequence of subtle behaviors initiated by a triggering antecedent, that culminate in biting.

Then you just start redirecting earlier in the sequence.

It’s also important to break up patterns in your response to the behavior.

Assuming you are a human and not a perfect dog training robot, sometimes you won’t catch the sequence early enough. And Sparky will bite.

When she does, don’t respond the same way every time. Sometimes you’ll ask her to sit, sometimes you’ll put her in her crate for naptime, sometimes you’ll disengage and leave the pen for a minute before coming back with a tug toy.