So you noticed out of the corner of your eye that Chomper the puppy approached your old dog Fido and started annoying him. Either jumping up in his face or sniffing at the toy he was chewing on. Suddenly, Fido’s snarling and lunging at Chomper, and Chomper’s screaming bloody murder.
What are you supposed to do?
First of all, Fido correcting Chomper isn’t inherently a bad thing. It can actually be a good thing; appropriate corrections from an adult dog can teach puppies about proper canine etiquette in a way that humans can’t.
Key word being appropriate corrections. It needs to be a measured response, not an attack or an actual bite.
Good corrections involve:
Provocation, meaning the puppy was actively bothering Fido. He didn’t just rush across the room to attack the puppy, or snap at her when she wasn’t engaging with him.
Avoidance before any type of aggressive display. “Corrections” do not always mean a snap or a snarl. Healthy, socially-savvy adult dogs will first correct puppies by removing their attention. So they disengage from play, or walk away. They may growl while they do this. In this video from the Biting course, there’s a clip of baby Hazel getting too wild, and River correcting her by disengaging from their game.
Warning behavior before they escalate. Like a freeze, a look-away, a lip curl, or a growl. (Warning behavior can be super subtle. A good understanding of Dog Speak is critical when you have multiple dogs)
If they must escalate, they give the correction and then back off. The snap-lunge doesn’t last more than about three seconds. If Fido keeps snapping, bites down and holds on, or keeps Chomper pinned even after Chomper’s crying “uncle,” separate them immediately.
No damage. No tooth-to-fur contact, or minimal tooth-to-fur contact.
The way the puppy reacts is helpful information, too. They might scream bloody murder, but that’s an instinctive reaction that’s all part of the ritual of warning behavior. If they shake it off and try to re-engage later, that means it’s within the range of normal.
So if Fido snaps, Chomper yelps out an “okay sorry!” and both dogs move on, you don’t have to worry. But maybe separate them for a minute to cool off. You can and should offer comfort to both dogs during this separation.
But if Chomper doesn’t take the hint and keeps bothering Fido, take her away and keep them separated for a while.
Bottom line: Escalated (snarl/snap) corrections in and of themselves are not a huge deal, and you should not punish Fido for them.
See the Dog-to-Dog Communication lesson from the Understanding Your Puppy course.
But still, you don’t want Fido to be in the position of constantly having to defend himself from the demon puppy.
When to prevent corrections
How’s Fido’s mental health? If he seems happy to actively engage with Chomper and have her around and only occasionally gives a “whoa kid, too much” correction, great! You don’t have to worry.
But if he seems unhappy, overwhelmed, or not like himself? Being in the position of constantly having to fend off the demon puppy will create too much stress and lead to a strained relationship between the two.
And if he’s elderly (typically age 12 and up), sick or injured, or has chronic pain issues, only allow interactions when the puppy is in a relatively chill mood. Always give them a break at the first sign of an avoidance correction – and ideally, before that. I would not force unhealthy or weak dogs to endure puppy chaos unless they were clearly having a good time.
Help your puppy learn about consent
Just like babies aren’t born knowing the finer points of human communication, puppies aren’t born with a perfect understanding of canine communication. And while us humans can’t exactly teach puppies how to speak dog, we can offer assistance.
Watch your adult dog for signs he’s giving an avoidance correction. If he disengages from play, tries to walk away, jumps on the couch to get out of reach, or looks up at you with pleading “save me!” eyes, and the puppy does not get the hint, calmly separate them. Either call the puppy away in a happy, excited tone, or pick them up.
This does two things:
- It helps the puppy learn to observe dog body language, even if only in a rudimentary fashion. “If I tackle Uncle Fido when he’s avoiding me, I get taken away from the fun! Maybe I should not tackle Uncle Fido when he avoids me.”
- It teaches Fido that you’ve got his back, and you’ll take charge if he’s unhappy so that he doesn’t have to escalate.
When in doubt
Err on the side of too much management, instead of not enough.
When in doubt, separate the dogs. Never rely on them “working it out themselves.”
If Fido has any history of aggression toward dogs, or if he was under-socialized and not great at inter-canine interactions, prevention is critical. No corrections allowed.
And if you’re just unsure of how Fido behaves with other dogs, stay vigilant until you’ve seen enough interactions between Fido and Chomper that you have a clear picture of Fido’s puppy skills and tolerance level. Prioritize management and prevention and the Puppy Means Treats exercise from the last lesson.
