Three ways we use food and other good stuff

When coaching for fear and aggression, we use food and other “good stuff” to improve your dog’s behavior.

We’ll typically use these good things in three ways:

1. Positive reinforcement – part of the operant conditioning learning system

You’ll probably recognize this one, since we’ve had you do some positive reinforcement stuff already. This is your classic “dog training:” Changing behavior by teaching dogs to do specific things. Do the trick, get a treat.

Positive reinforcement is useful for fearful or aggressive dogs because it teaches them new skills they can use to handle situations that trigger them.

Examples:

Training a dog to lie on a mat can give them a clear task to do when they feel uncertain.

Training a hand target gives you a way to quickly create distance between the dog and a potential trigger.

Training dogs to look at you when they see a trigger (Observation Game, etc) can replace their original, unwanted response of barking or lunging when they see a trigger.

2. Counter-conditioning and Desensitization (DSCC) – part of the classical conditioning learning system

This is about changing emotion, and therefore indirectly changing behavior. It’s about addressing a problem at the motivation level.

Desensitization means gradually exposing a dog to the trigger (aka the Scary Thing) in doses that are small enough that the dog doesn’t react negatively. The dog gradually becomes less sensitive (less scared, less reactive, less angry) to the trigger.

If your dog is nervous around strangers, we’d first figure out the dose of encountering a stranger that doesn’t upset them. Maybe they’re okay seeing strangers walk past 30 feet away. Great! So now we instruct you to hang out in an area where they can observe strangers who get no closer than 30 feet away, and let your dog realize “hey, this isn’t so bad!”

Counter-conditioning means changing the way the dog feels about the Scary Thing, by changing what happens when they see it. You give them something good every time they see the Scary Thing, so they learn that scary thing is a predictor of good things… and maybe even start to see it as a Good Thing itself.

Desensitization and counter-conditioning are often best used in combination with each other, which is why we’re referring to them as one method, DSCC for short.

Example:

For the dog who’s nervous around strangers, you might wait until a stranger appears 30 feet away, and give your dog a treat.

3. Management

This is all about physically preventing the unwanted behavior from occurring. You can do this using good timing, distractions, or physical barriers.

Examples:

For a dog who stares out the window and barks at passersby, management might mean putting up window film so they can’t see those triggers anymore.

For a resource guarding dog, you might put them in a separate area behind a baby gate when they’re eating, so that no one gets close enough to them to set off the guarding behavior.

For a reactive dog, it might mean walking your dog during less busy times, like early mornings, to avoid encountering other dogs.

It could also mean scattering treats on the ground to prevent your dog from seeing another dog walk by in the distance.

Management also includes “damage control” emergency measures. Where something bad is already happening, and you need to get out of the situation without making things worse.

For the resource guarding dog who’s grabbed your expensive shoe and is now growling at you, damage control might mean going to the fridge and getting a big chunk of yesterday’s pot roast and throwing it across the room to get them to chase it while you pick up the shoe.

(Yeah, damage control isn’t always elegant or pretty. Just necessary)

Management is never enough on its own, but it’s an important piece of a behavior modification plan.

Preventing problems means bad habits don’t become more entrenched. It can also help dogs relax and become more receptive to training, since they aren’t constantly experiencing stressful situations.

There’s overlap between all three

None of these exist in a vacuum; there’s usually some overlap.

The toddler who touches a hot burner is operantly conditioned not to touch hot burners. And you can bet he’s also been classically conditioned to have at least a little bit of a fearful reaction to stove tops.

Examples of overlap:

Using positive reinforcement to train a hand target means you now have a handy management tool that can be used to distract the dog from seeing a trigger.

Using positive reinforcement to train your dog to look at you when they see a trigger means your dog now associates the trigger with this fun training exercise, so through the power of counter-conditioning, they start to link the good feelings of the training exercise to the presence of the trigger.

And desensitizing a dog to a trigger can get them to a mental and emotional place where they can actually focus on the positively reinforced behaviors you’d like them to do instead.

The nuance of all of this will be accounted for in your training program.