Highlights and extra info
Operant conditioning: the realm of voluntary behavior
This is where an animal voluntarily adjusts their behavior based on the consequences of that behavior.
Reinforcement and punishment fall under this category. No matter what methods a trainer uses to train behaviors -whether they rely on treats or prong collars- they’re using operant conditioning. Do a trick, get a treat. Do something irritating, get a collar pop, etc.
Nerd Alert: Ever heard a dog trainer ramble on about the “four quadrants?” They’re talking about the four quadrants of operant conditioning:
- Positive reinforcement
- Negative reinforcement
- Positive punishment
- Negative punishment
The dog training sphere on social media LOVES to get into the weeds on all of these. But you probably don’t need to think about it much.
Classical conditioning: the realm of emotions and other involuntary responses
This is where an animal develops an involuntary response to a stimulus.
How do you feel when you hear your partner get home from work? What happens to your body and your heart rate when a rat/spider/suspicious stranger appears out of nowhere? Does your mouth start watering when you smell your favorite food?
Those are classically conditioned responses.
Desensitization and counter-conditioning, the top methods of handling fear and aggression in dogs, fall under the umbrella of classical conditioning.
How do you know which one to use?
When we’re trying to change behaviors that are annoying to humans but innocuous to the dog, one of the things we’ll do is use operant conditioning to control the consequences:
Make sure unwanted behavior doesn’t get accidentally rewarded, and train and reward the crap out of behavior you’d prefer. Behaviors we handle this way are stuff that is normal for dogs, but that humans consider bad manners.
Behaviors like:
- Destructive chewing
- Peeing on the carpet
- Digging up the garden
- Jumping on visitors
- Pulling on leash
- Stealing food off the table
- Begging
But when changing behavior that results from a dog being distressed, we have to address the emotion. A dog who is cowering in the corner, growling at your dinner party guests, is in a very different state from the dog who is begging your party guests for food, and needs a very different training approach – one based in classical conditioning.
To summarize:
- When a behavior is not based in distress, start with operant conditioning
- When a behavior is based in distress, start with classical conditioning
- You can’t reinforce fear or other emotions
- Any time you operantly condition a behavior, you can be certain a classically conditioned response is also being “installed.”
Things can definitely get more complex and nuanced than this, and your coaching program will account for this. But as long as you understand the fundamental difference between classical and operant conditioning, you’ll be better prepared to make good decisions for your dog’s training.
